2003 OTL Draft - Rounds 1-4
  Team Name Rnd 1 Rnd 2 Rnd 3 Rnd 4
1 Glen Wilton Joe Medwick Ty Cobb 1st Pick 22nd Pick
2 Ellerol 1st Pick 8th Pick 2nd Pick 21st Pick
3 Newark 2nd Pick 7th Pick 3rd Pick 20th Pick
4 Williamsburg 3rd Pick 6th Pick 4th Pick 19th Pick
5 Jimtown George Sisler Hank Aaron Ed Cicotte 18th Pick (Lincoln*3)
6 Lafayette 4th Pick 5th Pick 5th Pick 17th Pick
7 Cleveland Nap Lajoie Paul Waner Sam Leever Dave Righetti
8 Houston Pete Alexander Tim Keefe Gabby Hartnett Harry Heilman
9 Missouri Ted Abernathy 4th Pick 6th Pick 16th Pick
10 Princeton Rogers Hornsby Hank Greenberg Lady Baldwin 15th Pick
11 Lynchburg Al Rosen Joe Jackson 7th Pick 14th Pick
12 Wilmington George Brett Ed Walsh 8th Pick 13th Pick
13 Finnerton Joe Dimaggio Steve Carlton 9th Pick 12th Pick
14 Calcutta Babe Ruth John McGraw Ed Reulbach Sam Weever
15 Lincoln 5th Pick 3rd Pick 10th Pick 11th Pick
16 Motown 6th Pick 2nd Pick 11th Pick 10th Pick
17 Florida 3-Finger Brown BillHenry 12th Pick 9th Pick
18 Lakeland Joe Morgan Charlie Sweeney Stan Coveleski Jimtown*1 (Mickey Welch)
19 Pleasant Grove Mark McGwire Harmon Killebrew 13th Pick 8th Pick
20 Ghosts of '69 Hugh Duffy Cy Young 14th Pick 7th Pick
21 Texas 7th Pick 1st Pick 15th Pick 6th Pick
22 Springfield Tip O'Neill Arky Vaughn Guy Hecker 5th Pick
23 Northside Chuck Klein Willie Wells Jack Chesbro 4th Pick
24 Zzyzx Dusty Rhodes Josh Gibson Denny Driscoll 3rd Pick
25 Memphis Ed Delahanty Ed Morris John Ward 2nd Pick
26 Framingham Addie Joss Christy Mathewson Lou Gehrig Ted Williams
27 Oroville Dennis Eckersley William Bell 16th Pick 1st Pick
28 Seattle Willie Mays Mickey Mantle Walter Johnson  Silver King
*1 = fm Lakeland
*2 = fm Lynchburg
*3 = fm Jimtown