| 2007 OTL Draft - Rounds 1-4 | ||||||
| Team Name | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | ||
| 1 | Cabrini | Jim McCormick | Lady Baldwin | Ted Kluszewski | Jesse Burkett | |
| 2 | Calcutta | Babe Ruth | John McGraw | Ed Reulbach | Steve Rogers | |
| 3 | Florida | Heinie Berger | Lefty Leifield | Dean Chance | Joe Williams | |
| 4 | 
|
Lou Gehrig | Ted Williams | Addie Joss | Christy Mathewson | |
| 5 |
|
Norm Cash | Babe Adams | Silver King | Joe Borden | |
| 6 | Glen Wilton | Mel Ott | Rogers Hornsby | Ferdie Schupp | George Winter | |
| 7 | Houston | Tuck Turner | Orval Overall | Billy Rhines | Mike Tiernan | |
| 8 | Jimtown | Cupid Childs | Cherokee Fisher | Al Spalding | Charlie Hodnett | |
| 9 | Lafayette | Billy Hamilton | Barney Pelty | Elmer Steele | Tommy Bond | |
| 10 | Las Vegas | Hack wilson | Sam Thompson | Ed Morris | Harry Krause | |
| 11 | League City | Jeff Bagwell #1 Pick | Vean Gregg | Hippo Vaughn | Joe Morgan | |
| 12 | Louisville | George Sisler | Joe Dimaggio | Cy Young | J.R. Richard | |
| 13 | 
|
Hugh Duffy | Bill Donovan | Bill Bernard | Steve Carlton | |
| 14 | Naugatuck | Charlie Gehringer | Hank Greenberg | Stan Coveleski | Ray Collins | |
| 15 | New Canaan | Doc White | Eppa Rixey | Nick Altrock | Jackie Robinson | |
| 16 | Newark | Eddie Collins | Wade Boggs | Lee Richmond | Tug McGraw | |
| 17 | North Shore | Eddie Cicotte | Jim Devlin | Lefty Tyler | Joe Medwick | |
| 18 | Oakland | Hughie Jennings | Stan Musial | Bob Gibson | Dutch Leonard | |
| 19 | Oceanside | Babe Herman | Nap Lajoie | Ed Walsh | Mordecai Brown | |
| 20 |
|
Fred Clarke | Jimme Foxx | Bill Burns | Dennis Eckersley | |
| 21 |
|
Josh Gibson | Rube Waddell | Walter Johnson | Tris Speaker | |
| 22 | Salem | Bill Foster | Russ Ford | Rube Marquard | Frank Smith | |
| 23 | Seattle | Mickey Mantle | Willie Mays | Charley Sweeney | Pete Alexander | |
| 24 | Springfield | Arky Vaughan | Lefty O'Doul | Eddie Plank | Guy Hecker | |
| 25 | St. Louis | Ed Delahanty | Ty Cobb | Carl Hubbell | William Bell | |
| 26 |
|
Bill Terry | Ross Barnes | Jack Pfiester | Toad Ramsey | |
| 27 | Utah | Tip O'Neill | Chief Bender | Henry Boyle | Levi Meyerle | |
| 28 | Williamsburg | Frankie Frisch | Larry Walker | Carl Lundgren | John Clarkson | |
| 29 | Wilmington | George Brett | Bill Joyce | Bill Dickey | Joe Kelly | |
| 30 | Zzyzx | Denny Driscoll | Al Simmons | Jack Clements | John Weyhing | |
| Bold = Protected Players | ** = No List Submitted | Red = Selected in the Draft | ||||